Pepperidge Farm Goldfish Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese. New! Finn. Mac & cheese. Made with real cheese. See side panel for other sauce ingredients. Comix by Finn. I will now make a bowl of cheddar mac 'n' cheese disappear! Close your eyes, Gilbert. O.K. Abracadabra! Wow, Brooke! How'd you do that!! A magician never reveals her secrets. Try all 4 awesome varieties! No artificial preservatives. For questions or comments, please call 1-888-737-7374. Thank you.